I visited both GF and WL during our last trip. They are both really nice!! I think you will be happy no matter which one you choose
. The WL seemed more cozy with the fireplaces, etc. The GF seemed more luxurious and airy (and the beach was really nice). So, for me it would depend on the time of year. In the spring and summer I would go for the GF and in the fall and winter I would opt for the WL.